DISCUSSION QUESTIONS

THE UNITED STATES FROM THE 1920s
TO THE PRESENT (HI226)

syllabus


Over the course of the semester you must answer 5 sets of questions.  These will be graded on a pass/fail basis.  Your answers to each of the five sets of questions should be 1.5 pages.  These are due in class on the day that the reading is assigned.  Additionally, students will write one major (4-5 pages) and one minor (1.5-2 pages) book review.  Book reviews will be based on the supplemental books.  (Review questions and a guide to writing reviews will be placed on the web.)  Graded on a 1-100 scale, reviews must be handed in during class on the day they are due.


SCHEDULE OF READINGS

(All readings are to be completed on the day they are listed.) 

WEEK 1 - COURSE INTRODUCTION
THUR January 31: Syllabus review and course intro

   
WEEK 2 - ROARING 20s & CLASH OF CULTURES
MON February 4: Last day to register for a class

TUES February 5: Faragher, Out of Many, pgs. 616-622; The Way We Lived, Chapter 8, “Morals and Manners in the 1920s,” course pack (CP)
Set 1: Answer all 3.

1) John D’Emilio and Estelle Friedman “The Sexual Revolution.” Why did sociologists Robert and Helen Lynd chose a Midwestern town for their 1929 study Middletown?  How was the Muncie, Indiana of the 1890s different than the Muncie, Indiana of the 1920s? 

2) What do the authors mean when they write that adolescents now moved in a “youth-centered world”? 

3) Senator Henry Meyers, “Moving Pictures Evoke Concern, 1922.”  According to Senator Meyers, at their best what could movies accomplish for society?  But, in fact, how did he think movies changed society?  What did he offer as a solution?

THUR February 7: Faragher, pgs. 622-630; The Way We Lived, “Intolerance: A Bitter Legacy of Social Change,” CP
Set 2:  Answer any 3 out of the 5 questions. 

1) According to the historian David Chalmers, why did the Ku Klux Klan become such a powerful organization in the 1920s?  In the years after the Civil War, the first generation KKK was limited to the southern states.  How did it infiltrate the North and West in the ‘20s? 

2) Who were some of the Klan’s chief targets?  Why? 

3) In “The Klan’s Fight for Americanism, 1926,” Hiram Evans made the case for the Klan as the ultimate patriotic institution.  How did he and the KKK define “American”?  What does he mean by the Klan’s “trilogy”?

4) “Congress Debates Immigration Restriction, 1921.”  What kinds of arguments did the two congressmen make concerning immigration restriction? 

5) How did the 1951 Senate Committee deal with the issue thirty years later?  Are arguments similar to these two made in our day?


WEEK 3 - 1920s CONT., ECONOMIC CRASH, & ONSET OF THE DEPRESSION
MON February 11: Last day to drop/add class
   
TUES February 12: Faragher, pgs. 630-641; “Disbelief May Bar Volunteer Counsel at Evolution Trial” (Washington Post, 5/27/25), CP; Thomas E. Terrill, “Religion and Culture in the New South,” CP; H. L. Mencken, “The Hills of Zion” and “In Memoriam: W. J. B.,” CP

Set 3: Answer 3 of the 5.

1) “Disbelief May Bar Volunteer Counsel at Evolution Trial” (Washington Post, 5/27/25).  Why did Clarence Darrow come under the suspicion of observers of the Dayton, Tennessee trial?  What was at stake for both sides in this conflict?

2) Thomas E. Terrill, “Religion and Culture in the New South.”  What was the Butler Act?  What role would the ACLU play in the 1925 Scopes trial? 

3) Describe the area around Dayton Tennessee.  How did journalist H. L. Mencken view the trial?

4) H. L. Mencken, “The Hills of Zion” and “In Memoriam: W. J. B.”  Describe Mencken’s depiction of Dayton, Tennessee.  How did he portray the people of the hill country?

5) How does Mencken employ irony and sarcasm in his stinging obituary of W. J. Bryan?  What sort of a journalist and cultural commentator does Mencken strike you as? 

THUR February 14: Faragher, pgs. 644-650; The Way We Lived, Chapter 10, “The Depression Years,” CP

Set 4: Answer all 3.

1) “The Great Depression in Philadelphia, 1933.”  How did the 400 families in this selection manage to survive the onslaughts of the Great Depression?  What role did the government play in aiding them?  Why do you think these people responded so favorably to Franklin Roosevelt’s New Deal? 

2) “The Okies in California, 1939.”  Describe the living conditions of the new arrivals who had ventured to California.  How did these people survive?  Why do you suppose they would have wanted to come out west?” 

3) “The Bronx Slave Market, 1935.”  What was the Bronx slave market?  Why did these African-American women seek such menial jobs?  What does this piece say about the plight of blacks, as compared to the plight of whites, during the Depression years?


WEEK 4 - THE GREAT DEPRESSION & THE NEW DEAL

TUES February 19: Faragher, pgs. 650-57

THUR February 21: Faragher, pgs. 658-667; “Huge Dust Cloud, Blown 1,500 Miles, Dims City 5 Hours” (New York Times, 5/12/34), CP; “In the Land Made Desolate by Drought” (New York Times, 7/ 22/34), CP

Set 5: Answer 3 of the 4.

1) “Huge Dust Cloud, Blown 1,500 Miles, Dims City 5 Hours” (New York Times, 5/12/34).  How did the dust storms of the Midwest alter the atmosphere in New York City?  How did the city respond?

2) “In the Land Made Desolate by Drought” (New York Times, 7/ 22/34).  What impact did the crisis on the Great Plains have on the rest of the United States?

3) How did the farm families interviewed here respond to the harsh changes of the decade?  In what ways did the environmental trouble influence their livelihoods?

4) Judging from this article, what was the government response to the crisis? 


WEEK 5 - THE GREAT DEPRESSION, THE NEW DEAL, & WORLD WAR II

TUES February 26: Read Timothy Egan, The Worst Hard Time: The Untold Story of Those Who Survived the Great American Dust Bowl, and turn in short reaction paper or four-page review essay. 
Over the course of the semester, you will need to write one longer book review (4-5 pgs) and two shorter ones (1.5-2 pgs).  You may choose to complete either for this assignment  Remember, you will be graded on style, form, and content.  Answer one of the questions below and read this writing guide for further details.  Make sure to indicate on your paper which question (1 or 2) you answer.
Question 1: Timothy Egan describes the midwestern farming boom that lasted well into the 1920s. According to Egan, how did the land grab and heavy farming alter the high plains?  How did sodbusters and ranchers meet the many challenges of the 1930s? 

Question 2: Timothy Egan writes that “it may seem that most people just hurried through the southern plains or left in horror. . . . Yet most people living in the center of the Dust Bowl, about two thirds of the population in 1930, never left during that hard decade” (9-10).  Write a review essay on The Hard Worst Hard Time examining the various reasons why settlers stayed.

THUR February 28: Faragher, pgs. 672-685; The Way We Lived, Chapter 11, “World War II: The Home Front,” CP; Roger W. Lotchin, “Turning the Good War Home Front Bad: Historians’ Counterattack on the Greatest Generation” (Historically Speaking, Sept/Oct 2005), CP
Set 6: Answer 3 questions from section A and 1 from section B.

Section A

1) Augusta H. Clawson, “Shipyard Diary of a Woman Welder (1940s), 1944.”  What sort of challenges did Clawson face in her work as a welder?  How did she adapt to these? 

2) “Conditions in the [Japanese Internment] Camps” (1942-1945) Franklin Roosevelt signed Executive Order 9066 on February 19, 1942.  Through this law, 120,000 persons (2/3 of them American citizens) were confined to concentration camps on American soil, in some cases for nearly 4 years.  The law mentioned no ethnic or racial group by name but it was obviously intended to apply to Japanese-Americans.  What were the conditions like in these camps? 

3) Should certain people lose there rights during times of national emergency?  Are there similarities between what Japanese-Americans faced during WW II and what Americans of Middle Eastern descent faced in post-9/11 America? 

4) During WW II, there were no camps for U. S. “civilians” of German or Italian descent.  Why was this the case? 

Section B 
5) Roger W. Lotchin, “Turning the Good War Home Front Bad: Historians’ Counterattack on the Greatest Generation” (Historically Speaking, Sept/Oct 2005).  What is Roger Lotchin’s chief criticism concerning how historians treat the U. S. home front? 

6) What does Lotchin think is missing in histories of WW II?
 

WEEK 6 - WORLD WAR II CONT.
TUES March 4: Faragher, pgs. 685-699

THUR March 6: Read Michael C. C. Adams, The Best War Ever: America and World War II, and turn in short reaction paper or four-page review essay.
Over the course of the semester, you will need to write one longer book review (4-5 pgs) and two shorter ones (1.5-2 pgs).  You may choose to complete either for this assignment  Remember, you will be graded on style, form, and content.  Answer one of the questions below and read this writing guide for further details.  Make sure to indicate on your paper which question (1 or 2) you answer.
Question 1: What does the title of Michael C. C. Adams book, The Best War Ever, mean?  Write an essay analyzing the ways in which that title draws together the author's many themes.  Does Adams make a strong argument?  Why or why not? 

Question 2: In The Best War Ever, historian Michael C. C. Adams describes the many changes American society underwent during the WW II era—including, the growth of big business, the emergence of a new youth culture, the breakdown in traditional values, and racial and gender upheavals.  How does Adams asses these transformations?  Are his conclusions sound?  Why or why not?


WEEK 7 - SPRING BREAK, MARCH 10-14

WEEK 8 - MIDTERM EXAM
TUES March 18: Midterm Exam. Midterm exam studyguide.

THUR March 20: No class


WEEK 9 - COLD WAR & AMERICA AT MID-CENTURY
TUES March 25: Faragher, pgs. 706-716; The Way We Lived, Chapter 12, “Moving to Suburbia: Dreams and Discontents,” CP
Set 7: Answer all 3.

1) Kenneth Jackson, “The Baby Boom and the Age of the Subdivision.”  What was the housing situation in the U.S. like immediately after World War II? 

2) According to Jackson, why were families drawn to Levittown and other suburbs like it?  What did these Americans find so appealing about such new communities? 

3) Describe some of the distinguishing features of Levittown.  Some architectural and social critics reacted negatively to these new suburbs.  Why did these detractors despise Levittown?  Does their critique apply to modern suburbs?

*WED March 26, 3:30 pm: Randall Balmer (Columbia University), "God in the White House: Faith and the Modern Presidency." Lecture sponsored by the De Freitas Foundation. ENC, Shrader 15.

THUR March 27: Faragher, pgs. 716-732; Brian Ward, “‘Too much monkey business’: Race, Rock and Resistance” in Ward, Just My Soul Responding: Rhythm and Blues, Black Consciousness, and Race Relations (1998), CP

Set 8: Answer three of the four questions below.

1)  Historian Brian Ward notes that in 1956, “various forces of resistance to” rhythm and blues and biracial rock “intensified their efforts to halt its spread” (Ward 90).  How and why did the opponents of this new music lash out?  What were these detractors reacting to? 

2)  What does the April 1956 attack on Nat King Cole tell us about white southern views concerning race and music?

3) Describe the activities of the White Citizens Council in 1956.  What was that organization’s strategy and tactics? 

4) How does Ward use the feud between BMI and ASCAP to make a larger point?


WEEK 10 - AMERICA AT MID-CENTURY CONT.
MON March 31: Last day to withdraw or take a course as pass/fail or audit

TUES April 1: Faragher, pgs. 738-747; “Why Do the Girls Love Elvis” (Richmond Times-Dispatch, 7/22/56), CP; letters from the Assemblies of God archives, 1956, CP; David Wilkerson, “Rock and Roll: The Devil’s Heartbeat” (Pentecostal Evangel, Springfield, MO, 7/12/59), CP
Set 9: Answer all three

1) How does the author of “Why Do the Girls Love Elvis” describe the so-called “three button man”?  What sort of picture of Presley does the writer offer? 

2) Rev. David Wilkerson--who later wrote The Cross and the Switchblade and founded the youth ministry, Teen Challenge--certainly was no fan of rock.  Why was he so opposed to it?  Was Wilkerson's position similar to that of the anti-rock critics Brian Ward writes about? 

3) Describe the exchange between Mrs. Earl H. Clements and Ralph Riggs, a leader of the Assemblies of God church.  What was at stake for Clements?

THUR April 3: No class


WEEK 11 - AMERICA AT MID-CENTURY CONT.
TUES April 8: Read Jack Kerouac, On the Road: 50th Anniversary Edition.

Over the course of the semester, you will need to write one longer book review (4-5 pgs) and two shorter ones (1.5-2 pgs).  You may choose to complete either for this assignment  Remember, you will be graded on style, form, and content.  Asnwer question 5 or 6 for your review.  Questions 1-4 are for our in-class discussion. Read this writing guide for further details.  Make sure to indicate on your paper which question (5 or 6) you answer. The questions below are adapted from Penguin’s Reading Guide.

In-class discussion questions

1) What part do women play in the core emotional relationship between Sal and Dean?  How does the novel reflect the roles of men and women in this period of history?
      
2) At the end of every adventure with Dean Moriarty, Sal Paradise returns home to his aunt, in Paterson, New Jersey. Is Kerouac's novel a convincing demonstration that mainstream middle-and-working-class values are inherently incompatible with the Beat lifestyle and philosophy of the road?
      
3) Whenever Sal and Dean have the chance to hear music, they choose jazz. What explains the dedication these characters have for this sophisticated African-American urban art form? What does Kerouac believe the jazz musician represents?
      
4) Almost every time that Paradise waxes poetic about heaven, God, and the road, shortly thereafter the topic of Death rears its head.  Describe how religion and larger questions about existence play out in the book.  How do Kerouac’s views on the subject compare to those of other Americans in this era?

Book review questions:  Choose one

5) Some critics have claimed that the world Kerouac depicts in On the Road glorifies the deeds of uneducated, criminal young men leading irresponsible lives, committing sacrilegious acts. Given today's low tolerance for youthful rebellion, particularly drug use, do you find the behavior of Dean Moriarty and Sal Paradise repugnant and totally inappropriate? Do you think Kerouac is approving or critical of his characters' behavior?
      
6) Why do you think On the Road, after more than forty years since its original publication, still maintains a magnetic hold on American youth culture? Is the novel's significance to your generation different from its significance to younger and to older generations? How has the meaning of On the Road changed for you since your first encounter with it?


THUR April 10: Faragher, pgs. 747-756; W. J. Rorabaugh, “Introduction” in Kennedy and the Promise of the Sixties (2002), CP

Set 10: Answer all four

1) According to W. J. Rorabaugh, what made the 1960s a “promising time”?

2) What were some of the dark undercurrents of the early sixties?  What problems threatened the order and seeming stability of the era?

3) How was the “tone” of the sixties different than that of the fifties?

4) Why does Rorabaugh argue that the “more one thinks about the early sixties as a slice of time the more one is forced to focus on the curious figure of John Kennedy”? (xx)


WEEK 12 - THE BLACK FREEDOM STRUGGLE   
TUES April 15: Advising day, no classes

*WED April 16, 7 pm: Donald Yerxa (ENC), “That Embarrassing Dream: Big Questions and the Limits of History,” with a response from Jon Roberts (Boston University). ENC Munro Parlor.

THUR April 17: Faragher, pgs. 762-787; The Way We Lived, Chapter 13, “The Black Struggle for Equality,” CP
Set 11: Answer all 3.

1) How did the U. S. Supreme Court make it’s 1954 ruling in Brown vs Topeka Board of Education?  What sort of evidence did the Court use to make its case?

2) Congressman James Whitten of Mississippi (Democrat) was a member of the U.S. House from 1941 to 1995, setting a record for length of service.  Why did Whitten think that America’s legislative body was destroying the Constitution and violating “every intent of the founders of our Republic”? (250)  How did he make this argument?

3) Describe the different treatment whites and blacks received according to Howell Raines in his Growing Up Black in the South. How did he respond to those circumstances?


WEEK 13 - THE CLASH OF CULTURES IN THE SIXTIES
TUES April 22: Faragher, pgs. 792-805; The Way We Lived, Chapter 14, “The Sixties: A Decade of Protest,” CP

Set 12: Answer all 3.

1) “Port Huron Statement, 1962,” drafted by Tom Hayden, co-founder of the Students for a Democratic Society (268-73).  What were the young members of the SDS reacting against?  What did they find so disturbing about American culture? 

2) Hayden quotes one observer of college-age Americans who remarked, “Students don’t even give a damn about the apathy” (272).  Moreover, Hayden’s “Port Huron Statement” condemned college students as passive, uninterested in the duties of citizenship, and unwilling to take risks.  They were, says Hayden, more interested in their future careers and securing good marriages than in worldwide suffering or intellectual pursuits.  Are college students today more “active” and “socially aware” than those Hayden discribed?  Why or why not? 

3) John Kerry, “Vietnam Vets Against the War, 1971” (273-75).  Vietnam veteran John Kerry offered a list of war-related grievances to a U.S. Senate committee in 1971.  What were some of these?  Why did Kerry describe the war as a “chance to die for the biggest nothing in history. . .” (274). 

*TUES April 22, 7 pm: Grant Wacker (Duke University) lecture at ENC: "Exporting the Soul of Dixie: Billy Graham and the Expansion of Southern Culture"
   
THUR April 24: Faragher, pgs. 805-823; “Robert S. McNamara Urges Additional Troop Deployments, 1965” and “George F. Kennan Criticizes the American Military Commitment, 1966” in Robert J. McMahon, ed., Major Problems in the History of the Vietnam War, CP

Set 13: Answer all 3.

1) What did Secretary of Defense Robert McNamara see as some of the critical problems facing the US in Vietnam?  Describe the strategy he lays out in this selection. 

2) Why did George F. Kennan criticize US involvement in Vietnam?  How did his opinion contrast to McNamara’s? 

3) Who made the better case?  Why?


WEEK 14 - THE 1970s
TUES April 29: Faragher, pgs. 832-848

THUR May 1: Change in schedule: Andreas Killen book moved to Tues, May 6. Read Faragher, pgs. 848-860.


WEEK 15 - THE 1980s

TUES May 6: Read Andreas Killen, 1973 Nervous Breakdown: Watergate, Warhol, and the Birth of Post-Sixties America, and turn in short reaction paper or four-page review essay. Questions posted later; Haynes Johnson, “The Winner,” in Johnson, Sleepwalking Through History: America in the Reagan Years (1991), CP

Set 14: If completing your set on Haynes Johnson selection, provide a general summary.

Over the course of the semester, you will need to write one longer book review (4-5 pgs) and two shorter ones (1.5-2 pgs).  You may choose to complete either for this assignment.  Remember, you will be graded on style, form, and content.  Asnwer question 1 or 2 for your paper.  Read this writing guide for further details.  Make sure to indicate on your paper which question (5 or 6) you answer.

1. According to Andreas Killen, how did 1973 mark an end of the 1960s and the birth of a new cultural sensibility?

2. Explain what Andreas Killen means by his title, 1973 Nervous Breakdown. How does that phrase relate to the events of the era?


THUR May 8: Reading day, no class

WEEK 16 - Final Exam - Final exam studyguide
MON May 12, 3:30 PM - 5:30 PM


The James R. Cameron Center for History, Law, & Governrnent  | Eastern Nazarene College | 23 East Elm Avenue  | Quincy, Massachusetts 02170  | Phone: 1-617-745-3000  |  email: r a n d a l l . s t e p h e n s @ e n c . e d u


Site designed by Randall J. Stephens

Maps & Directions