DISCUSSION QUESTIONS

COLONIAL TO REVOLUTIONARY AMERICA
(HI223)

syllabus


Over the course of the semester you must answer 5 sets of questions.  These will be graded on a pass/fail basis.  Your answers to each of the five sets of questions should be 1.5 pages.  These are due in class on the day that the reading is assigned.  Additionally, students will write one major (4-5 pages) and one minor (1.5-2 pages) book review.  Book reviews will be based on the supplemental books.  (Review questions and a guide to writing reviews will be placed on the web.)  Graded on a 1-100 scale, reviews must be handed in during class on the day they are due.


Failure to complete any of the assignments will obviously result in a significant lowering of your total grade.  If this all seems too daunting, remember that the last day to drop a course with no penalties is Sept 14.

SCHEDULE OF READINGS
(All readings are to be completed on the day they are listed.)

WEEK 1 - COURSE INTRODUCTION
THURS SEPT 1: Course intro, syllabus review, guidelines.

WEEK 2 - PRE-COLUMBIAN AMERICA TO 1500
TUES SEPT 7: Faragher, Out of Many, 2-14; Mary Beth Norton, “History Under Construction in Florida,” New York Times, 2 July 2006 (course pack CP).

THUR SEPT 9: Out of Many, 15-21; Bernardino de Sahagun, A History of Ancient Mexico (CP)

Set 1: Answer all three.

1. Judging from Sahagun, what purpose do the Aztec rituals serve?

2. How do the Aztecs treat the victims of sacrifice?

3. How did Aztec religion and culture differ from that of the West?


WEEK 3 - PRE-COLOMBIAN AMERICA TO 1500, CONT., AND COLLISION OF CULTURES, 1492-1590
TUES SEPT 14: Out of Many, 26-38; “The First Americans,” 3-18 (CP). (Sept 14: Last day to drop a class.)

Set 2: Answer all three.

1. In the chapter of your primary text, Out of Many, the authors suggest that is is necessary for historians to understand the geography and climate of early America.  Describe some of the ways Indian peoples adjusted to different regions of North America.  According to the first essay in The Way We Lived, entitled “Algonquians and Iroquoians,” how did woodland Indians make full and efficient use of northeastern forests?

2. In what ways does Captain John Smith’s view of Indians (Way We Lived, p.13-15) differ from that of Mary Jemison (15-16)?  Why?

3. Does Red Jacket make a persuasive argument in the selection titled “An Indian’s View, 1805" (16-18)?  How might a devout Christian have responded to Red Jacket’s appeal?

THUR SEPT 16: Out of Many, 38-44. Online reading: Christopher Columbus, “Letter to Luis de Sant Angel” (1493); Bartolome de Las Casas, “Of the Island of Hispaniola” (I542); “William Bradford on Sickness among the Natives” (1633).
Set 3: Asnwer all three.

1. DOCUMENT: Christopher Columbus, “Letter to Luis de Sant’ Angel” (1493)
In this letter to one of his leading supporters in the Spanish court, Christopher Columbus describes his reaction to the sights of the New World. He is describing the island of Hispaniola, present-day Haiti and the Dominican Republic. QUESTIONS: According to this letter, what were Columbus’ goals in the New World?  How did the Spanish perceive the Indians in this document?

2. DOCUMENT: Bartolomé de Las Casas, "Of the Island of Hispaniola" (1542)
Bartolomé de Las Casas (1474-1566) was a Spanish missionary and historian.  He was known as the "Apostle of the Indians" for his exposing the European conquerors' brutal treatment of native peoples. QUESTIONS: Does Las Casas’s description of native Americans seem more reliable than the account of early explorers such as Christopher Columbus?  Why or why not?

3.DOCUMENT: "William Bradford on Sickness among the Natives" (1633)
Scholars call the passing of ideas, plants, animals, and diseases between the “Old” and “New” worlds the “Columbian exchange.”  Most devastating for the “Old World” population were new deadly pathogens, to which few Indians were immune.  In this document, William Bradford, a Pilgrim leader of Plymouth Massachusetts, describes the horrific effects of smallpox on New England tribes.  QUESTIONS: Judging from this document, what was the impact of smallpox on the Native Americans? What does William Bradford make of this disease?  What do you think of the effects of these diseases?


WEEK 4 - COLLISION OF CULTURES, 1492-1590
TUES SEPT 21: Out of Many, 48-56; Richard Hakluyt, Discourse of Western Planting (1584) (CP); “Conflicting Cultural Values in Early America” and “Husbands and Wives, Parents and Children in Puritan Society,” 31-55 (CP).
Set 4: Answer three of the four.
1. Why did Richard Hakluyt argue that the English should establish colonies?  Did his hopes match later realities?

2. "Virginia, A Troubled Colony, 1622," p. 31-33; "The Experiences of an Indentured Servant, 1623," p. 33-35; John Winthrop [distant ancestor of John Kerry] "Wee shall be as a Citty upon a Hill, 1630," p. 35-37.  What were some of the fundamental challenges colonists faced in early 17th century North America?  How did they attempt to meet these challenges? 

3. Steven Mintz and Susan Kellog, “The Godly Family in Massachusetts,” p. 39-50.
Why were families so important to the New England Puritans?  How were women and children treated in early Massachusetts?  Did Puritan families always operate according to the laws set up by church and state?  Provide an example to support your argument.

4. Anne Bradstreet, “Two Poems,” p. 50-51.  The term “puritanical” usually describes someone who is rigid, cold, and fanatically religious.  Would you characterize Anne Bradstreet’s poetry as “puritanical”?  Why or why not?  Were Puritans "puritanical" with regard to how they raised their children? (“A Law for ‘the good education of children,’ 1642," p. 51-52; “Monitoring Style and Behavior in Puritan Massachusetts, 1675,” 52-53; “Good Manners for Colonial Children, 1772,” p. 53-55.

THUR SEPT 23: Out of Many, 56-68. Online document by David D. Hall, “Witch Hunting in Salem: Why were 19 people hanged?”
Set 5: Answer the following.
 
  • According to David Hall, why were 19 people hanged in Salem, Massachusetts?  What were the issues that provoked this violent episode?

  • WEEK 5 - EARLY EUROPEAN COLONIES AND SOCIAL RELATIONS IN NORTH AMERICA NOTE THE CHANGE IN THE REDAING SCHEDULE (Tues and Thurs assignments have been switched).
    TUES SEPT 28: Out of Many, 74-86; “What are the origins of American Slavery?”; Peter Kolchin, American Slavery, 1619-1877, 28-49 (CP).

    Set 6: Using both Kolchin and the online reading, answer the two questions at the bottom of "What are the origins of American Slavery?"

    THUR SEPT 30: Jill Lepore, The Name of War: King Philip’s War and the Origins of American Identity, and turn in short reaction paper or four-page review essay. See questions for paper: www.enc.edu/history/HI223_qs.html. See writing guide: www.enc.edu/history/cr_writing.html.

    Answer one of the questions below and read this writing guide for further details.  Make sure to indicate on your paper which question (1, 2, or 3) you answer.

    1. Jill Lepore observes that war and the meaning of war are tied up in language.  How does Lepore use language to describe the context and impact of King Philip's War?  Those who asnwer this question should read the following sections from the book: "What's in a Name," ix-xxiii; chapter 1; chapter 2; chapter 7.

    2. According to Jill Lepore, Indians and English colonists had very different ideas about property, honor, suffering, religion, and more.  Describe the nature of those differences and summarize Lepore's argument about them. Those who asnwer this question should read the following sections from the book: "What's in a Name," ix-xxiii; prologue; chapter 3; chapter 4; chapter 8.

    3. How well does Jill Lepore describe what it was like to live in New England during this violent, turbulent era?  Give a detailed analysis of your answer. Those who asnwer this question should read the following sections from the book: "What's in a Name," ix-xxiii; prologue; chapter 3; chapter 5; chapter 6.


    WEEK 6 - EARLY EUROPEAN COLONIES AND SOCIAL RELATIONS IN NORTH AMERICA, CONT. AND RACE AND SLAVERY IN COLONIAL AMERICA
    TUES OCT 5: Out of Many, 86-98; “Crossing the Atlantic: The Experience of Slaves and Servants,” 72-76 (CP); Jacob Stoyer, My Life in the South (CP).
    Set 7: Answer all three questions.

    1. Olandah Equiano (Gustavus Vasa), "Voyage from Africa, 1756" 72-73.  Equiano was captured at age 12 in Benin, West Africa, and taken to the West Indies.  His account of the horrendous voyage to the New World inspired abolitionists for generations. Why was Equiano so terrified while aboard the slave ship?  How did the new slaves cope?

    2. Gottlieb Mittelberger, "An Immigrant's Journey, 1750." Gottlieb Mittelberger ventured from Germany to Pennsylvania in 1750 on a ship filled mostly with poor immigrants.  They were destined to become indentured servants upon arriving in Philadelphia.  Mittelberger was not one of these.  He taught school and was an organist for three years in the colonies before returning to Germany in 1754.  Do the experiences of the poor passengers aboard differ from the experiences of the newly enslaved Equiano describes?

    3. Selection from Jacob Stroyer's My Life in the South. Describe the scene Stroyer observed.  How were the slaves sent to market treated?  What does this document tell us about slavery in North America?

    THUR OCT 7: EXAM #1. Studyguide for exam 1.


    WEEK 7 - RELIGION AND CULTURE IN NORTH AMERICA
    TUES OCT 12: Out of Many, 102-109; “Letter of Father Paul Raguneau to the Very Reverend Father General, Vincent Caraffa” (1650) (CP).
    Set 8: Answer all three.

    1. How does the film we are watching, Black Robe, match what Father Ragueneau describes in this letter?  Does the movie seem to accurately depict the setting in New France?  Why or why not?

    2. What problems do the Jesuits, and Ragueneau in particular, face in the New World?  How do they meet these challenges?  

    3. How would you describe Ragueneau’s relationship with the Huron Indians? 

    THUR OCT 14: Thomas S. Kidd, The Great Awakening: A Brief History with Documents, and turn in short reaction paper or four-page review essay. See writing guide: www.enc.edu/history/cr_writing.html.

    Answer one of the questions below and read this writing guide for further details.  Make sure to indicate on your paper which question (1, 2, 3, or 4) you answer.

    1. Thomas Kidd writes that the “First Great Awakening of the mid-eighteenth century generated” a great deal of excitement and controversy (Kidd 2).  Why was that?

    2. Why did certain colonists support the revival (New Lights) and others oppose it (Old Lights)?  What cultural, social, and political factors led individuals to reject or embrace the Great Awakening?

    3. To what extent did the revival thrive because of the work of prominent ministers?  Use evidence from Thomas Kidd’s book to make your case.

    4. Was the revival a source of democratic and egalitarian ideals?  Why or why not?


    *Lecture Review or Extra Credit Opportunity: An ENC public lecture by Thomas Kidd (Baylor University), “God of Liberty: A Religious History of the American Revolution,” Friday, October 15, 3:00pm.


    WEEK 8 - CULTURE IN THE COLONIES
    TUES OCT 19: Out of Many, 109-113.

    THUR OCT 21: Out of Many, 113-123.

    WEEK 9 - CULTURE IN THE COLONIES, CONT.
    OCT 25-27: Midterm advising.  Out of Many, 128-135; “Urban Life in the 18th Century,” 95-111 (CP). (Oct 27: Last day to withdraw or change to pass/fail.)
    Set 9: Answer all three.

    Pauline Maier, "Boston and New York in the Eighteenth Century," p. 96-106 (CP)
    1. Descibe some of the features Boston and New York shared in the 18th century.  What were some of the cultural, social, political, and economic differences between the two port cities?

    "Benjamin Franklin's Union Fire Company," p. 106-7; and "Philadelphia," p. 107-8.
    2. Judging from these two documents, how did Philadelphia compare to Boston and New York in the 18th century?  What sort of picture do we have of the Quaker city based on the second piece?

    "The Scourge of Yellow Fever, Philadelphia, 1793," p. 109-11.
    3. In Matthew Carey's account, why did the yellow fever epidemic descend on Philadelphia?  How did public officials deal with the crisis?

    THUR OCT 28: Class tour of Adams National Historical Park. David Hackett Fischer, Albion’s Seed: Four British Folkways in America (CP).

    Set 10: Answer any three of the four.

    1. What are “folkways”?  How does David Hackett Fischer argue that we can better understand American history by looking at British folkways?

    2. How did religion influence what Fischer calls the “deathways” of Puritan New England? 

    3. What does Fischer mean by “gastronomic Puritanism”?  What does this tell us about early New Englanders?

    4. What role did sport, or “lawful recreation,” play in Puritan Massachusetts? 


    WEEK 10 - BECOMING AMERICAN
    TUES NOV 2: Out of Many, 135-151; excerpts from the Coercive Acts (1774) (CP).

    THUR NOV 4: Read Gordon S. Wood, The Americanization of Benjamin Franklin and turn in short reaction paper or four-page review essay. and turn in short reaction paper or four-page review essay. See questions for paper: www.enc.edu/history/HI223_qs.html. See writing guide: www.enc.edu/history/cr_writing.html.
    Answer one of the questions below and read this writing guide for further details.  Make sure to indicate on your paper which question (1 or 2) you answer.

    1. Judging from the introduction and conclusion of Gordon Wood’s biography, what are some of the enduring myths concerning Benjamin Franklin? Why do some celebrate and other’s scorn this founding father?

    2. What does Gordon Wood mean by the "Americanization" of Benjamin Franklin?

    *Lecture Review or Extra Credit Opportunity: An ENC public lecture by the Pulitzer Prize-winning historian Gordon Wood (Brown University) on early U.S. history, Thursday, November 4, at 7:00pm.


    WEEK 11- BECOMING AMERICAN, CONT.
    TUES NOV 9: EXAM #2. Studyguide for exam 2.

    TUES NOV 11: T. H. Breen, The Marketplace of Revolution: How Consumer Politics Shaped American Independence, xi-29 (CP).
    Set 11: Answer any three of the following.

    1. T. H. Breen writes that “common goods once spoke to power” (xii)  Explain what this statement means.

    2. What was the colonial “empire of goods” and the “consumer revolution”?  How do these help explain the Revolutionary era?

    3. How did Americans in the 1770s bridge their many differences to fight in a common cause?

    4. Why is Breen critical of the ideological interpretation of the American Revolution? (8-10)

    5. What was the “hospitable consumer”?


    WEEK 12 - THE WAR FOR INDEPENDENCE
    TUES NOV 16: Out of Many, 156-166.

    THUR NOV 18: “John Dickinson to Arthur Lee,” “Peter Oliver,” “To the Virginia Gazette,” “Jabez Fitch,” and “‘A Whig’” in The American Revolution: Writings from the War of Independence (CP).
    Set 12: Answer three of the five below.

    1. Describe the events that John Dickson wrote about in April 1775.  What questions did these events bring to Dickson’s mind?

    2. How does Peter Oliver’s account contrast with that of Dickson?  What explains this marked difference?  How did Oliver depict leading American patriots?

    3. According to the letter to the Virginia Gazette, why was Lord Dumore filled with “malice and treachery”? (81)  In the correspondent’s opinion, why did Dunmore issue his proclamation? In what sense might this document complicate a traditional view of the American Revolution? 

    4. Describe how British authorities treated Jabez Fitch.  What is Fitch’s opinion of Hessian troops?

    5. Why did the Whig in the final document think it necessary to deal harshly with Tories? Was banishment the best course?

    *Lecture Review or Extra Credit Opportunity: Jill Lepore (Harvard University) will deliver a lecture on colonial history at ENC on Thursday, November 18, at 7:00pm.


    WEEK 13 - THE WAR FOR INDEPENDENCE, CONT.
    TUES NOV 23: Out of Many, 166-178.

    THUR NOV 25: Thanksgiving break, NO CLASS.

    WEEK 14 - THE WAR FOR INDEPENDENCE, CONT., AND INVENTING A NATION
    TUES NOV 30: “People at War: Society during the American Revolution,” 124-129 (CP).
    Set 13: Answer both questions.

    1. “Remember the Ladies: Abigail and John Adams Exchange Views, 1776”
    In March, 1776, Abigail Adams asked her husband, John, to make sure the new nation’s laws would protect wives against the “natural tyranny” of their spouses. Why did Abigail plead this case? How does John Adams, who would become the second president of the United States, respond to her request?

    2. “Travails of a Loyalist Wife and Mother, 1777"
    This is a letter by Catherine Van Cortlandt, one of the 80,000 Tories, or those loyal to Britain, who would flee to safety. At the time Catherine Cortlandt wrote this letter to her husband, she and her children were trying to reach the Tory stronghold of New York. The Cortlandts, like many other families, did not support the cause of Revolution, and allied themselves with Britain. Many Patriots despised the British and their American allies for abridging colonists’ rights and levying what they considered to be unfair taxes on Americans. After reading this letter, do you think it is appropriate to describe the Cortlandts as traitors

    THUR DEC 2: Bernard Bailyn, To Begin the World Anew, 37-59 (CP).
    Set 14: Answer all four.
    1. Why is it so difficult for historians to understand Thomas Jefferson?  Why did his contemporaries, like historians, find so much about him to be contradictory and incongruous?

    2. Was Jefferson in any sense like his older contemporary, Benjamin Franklin? 

    3. How did Jefferson compare Americans with the French?  What did that comparison mean to him?

    4. Why did Jefferson oppose political parties, at least in principle, and challenge the Bank of the United States?

    WEEK 15 - Final Exam
    THUR DEC 9: 10:30 AM - 11:45 AM. Studyguide for 3 exam.




    The James R. Cameron Center for History, Law, & Governrnent  | Eastern Nazarene College | 23 East Elm Avenue  | Quincy, Massachusetts 02170  | Phone: 1-617-745-3000  |  email: r a n d a l l . s t e p h e n s @ e n c . e d u


    Site designed by Randall J. Stephens

    Maps & Directions